I think it is fair to say that International men’s day is a bit of a contentious issue.
Seemingly a response to international women’s day, one can't be blamed for feeling a bit uneasy about the prospect of celebrating men in the name of equality when it is the women who continue to fight for such a right.
And let's be frank, the perception of men at this moment in time is appalling. Between the Russell Brand conviction, the allegations against David Walliams and Noel Clarke, which remain unproven, difficult and important conversations are happening about what it means to be a man nowadays. This does not even take account of those manosphere fools we have previously written about.
I saw a tweet last week by a male public figure who I will not name, that simply said: “At this point you really can’t blame women for fearing all men”. I am not ashamed to admit this has stuck with me for the better part of a week as it really does conflict me. On the one hand, who am I as a man to pretend to have any idea what it could possibly be like to be a woman surrounded by youngsters touting Andrew Tate nonsense, hearing of friends being spiked in clubs and seeing household names jailed for historic sex offences? As a bloke, admittedly an anonymous one in this case, it does really make me wonder if I am just trundling along in a regretful state of blissful ignorance.
However, reading that tweet also immediately makes me think of countless blokes I’ve me or known over the years whom I cannot fathom women having even an inkling of fear of.
Whether you agree with the concept of an international day to celebrate men, I think it is important to continue to drive home the point that as men, we need to take a look at what is happening around us and realise that the only way to better this perception is to look inward. You and I cannot stop famous reprobates from abusing their power and harming the male reputation, but we can call out harmful attitudes and distance ourselves from them.
International men’s day is an opportunity to recognise their contributions blokes have and continue to make to society and highlight the issues that affect their lives. It is also an important moment to address abuse against men, even amongst the headlines which have rightfully focused on female victims.
Abuse does not discriminate. It can affect anyone, regardless of age, background, sexuality, relationship status or circumstances. Yet, for many men experiencing abuse, speaking out can feel almost impossible. Social expectations, stigma and misconceptions about masculinity can create barriers that prevent men from seeking the help and support they desperately need.
A pertinent example came in September, when former Liverpool and England striker Andy Carroll spoke out publicly about being sexually assaulted in his autobiography. Weeks later, he publicly named the perpetrator - television dance coach Kevin Adams, who was sentenced to 20 months in prison in 2023 in an interview with The Sun.
I was hesitant to write about it at the time as it was an example of someone opening up and doing something incredibly difficult, and even at the time, horrid things said on social media about him in the immediate aftermath.
While Caroll thanked the public for supporting him and for commending his bravery, it is not untrue to say this was not the universal response.
On the day to celebrate men internationally, it feels a good time to reference this. Andy Carroll has been a professional footballer for twenty years and played for one of the biggest clubs in the world, represented his country and scored at the Euros. If he can speak about his experiences, it should encourage others to do so as well. Even if one person feels compelled after hearing his story, then it was one worth telling.
Similar sentiments were echoed in Parliament at a backbench business committee debate on international men's day, brought forward by Labour MP Peter Swallow.
The Bracknell MP said: “International men’s day gives us an important opportunity to be very clear: a world in which we do not seriously reckon with both what it currently means and what we want it to mean to be a man or a boy today is a world that fails us all. “We should not be mealy-mouthed in calling out violence against women and girls and sex-based crimes. We can, and should, tackle these issues head-on. “Of course, we should also recognise and commit to supporting the male victims of domestic violence and sexual assault; these are men’s issues, too, and we need to be honest about that.”I think he has got this spot on here, namely because it has alluded to an old adage that we should all pay a bit more attention to sometimes: two things can be true. Swallow is absolutely right to reference horrific crimes committed against women and girls, but he is also right to say that males can indeed be victims too.
When people think about domestic abuse, sexual violence or emotional abuse, they may not immediately think about male victims. However, men can experience abuse in many forms, including physical violence, psychological and emotional manipulation, coercive control, financial abuse, sexual abuse, harassment and exploitation.
Abuse can happen within intimate relationships, marriages, families, friendships and other environments. It can take place behind closed doors, where the victim may feel trapped, frightened or unable to tell anyone what is happening.
We have previously written about stigma, fears of not being believed and even ridicule, but the long and short is that it's really difficult for some men to share their experiences like Carroll and others have done over the years.
This point was also addressed by Swallow in the debate, when he said men “disengage from seeking help” if they feel they have not been heard, and that the “tragic impacts of that disengagement can, and all too often do, reverberate out”. It is undeniably a good thing that this is being spoken of in Parliament. It is unequivocally encouraging that a man of Caroll’s stature was brave enough to share what happened to him. On this day to celebrate blokes, I certainly understand that we should be paying attention to the great work being done up and down the country to tackle the issues of declining male mental and high suicide rates. I also think it gives us an opportunity to evaluate who we are and how we can be better.
I am not going to ever be in a position to tell women what to fear, feel, love or hate. I am in a position to look inward and think about how I can be better as a man, and I hope this is something a lot of people do on this day, of all days.